Reddit's answer to "is SEO worth it" splits cleanly in two.
On SEO itself: yes, with patience. The most-quoted framing comes from a service-business thread: ads are hunting, SEO is gardening. Pay for ads, eat today, stop paying, starve. Plant SEO, wait three months, then it feeds you while you sleep. For local service businesses specifically, Reddit repeatedly calls local SEO the highest-return channel there is. The people who call SEO a waste usually quit early or bought badly.
On agencies: deep, earned cynicism. The same threads are full of owners five months and thousands of pounds in with nothing to show. Reddit's verdict on the industry: saturated with low-quality operators, worst at the cheap-package end, and so untrustworthy that the standing advice is "never hire anyone who approaches you on Reddit." One thread we read was carpeted in fake testimonials for the same agency, posted as different "customers". The astroturfing is so common that Redditors warn each other about it inside the threads.
So the real question is not "is SEO worth it". It is "how do I buy it without getting burned". Reddit answers that too, and it is the most useful thing in this whole page.
What the threads actually say.
Six threads that carry the whole debate. Every link goes to the real discussion, so you can check our reading of it.
An owner burned through four SEO companies in two years. Two produced nothing in ten months. The thread's top answer gave Reddit its favourite SEO metaphor: hunting vs gardening. And its most useful rule: you have a right to know exactly what work your provider did each month. If they can't tell you, that is the problem.
Read the thread on Reddit →An owner paying $1k a month plus $5k quarterly "link buys", upsold to $3k a month after five months of no results. The thread is unanimous: run. The lessons inside it: bought links are a red flag not a service, you should see movement by month three, and "it didn't work, pay us more" is confirmation, not a strategy.
Read the thread on Reddit →A founder weighing $5,000 for six months of SEO gets both barrels. One side: "the internet in 2025 is pay-to-play, do ads." The other: an owner who did their own SEO with ChatGPT and landed a high-value job from organic search. The thread's pricing rule of thumb, from an agency insider: under $500 a month is a complete scam, and around $500 means a beginner you should demand references from.
Read the thread on Reddit →A cabinet maker paid CA$2,200 and received a few keywords, two meta descriptions and some URL tweaks. Commenters priced the work at about $350. The deeper lesson in the thread: a poorly built website cannot be rescued by sprinkling SEO on top. The site is the foundation. If yours was built badly, fix that first.
Read the thread on Reddit →An Irish business nine months and €1,000 a month in, with improving numbers but "dubious quality" backlinks. The thread's sharpest point: there is no grey area on bought links. One real link from a relevant local partner beats dozens of purchased ones. And for a niche local business, a lot of SEO is front-loaded: build it right, then it mostly compounds.
Read the thread on Reddit →A thread asking for real experiences, which contains genuinely useful advice (an e-commerce owner whose revenue grew from $150k to $750k on the back of it) and also several near-identical fake testimonials plugging the same agency. Reddit's advice born from threads like this: never hire an SEO who found YOU on Reddit.
Read the thread on Reddit →Reddit's red flags.
Where we sit on Reddit's danger list.
Now the awkward bit. Reddit says the £500 to £1,000 monthly package tier is the danger zone, and our Foundations retainer is £600 a month. We are not going to pretend otherwise. The difference between a burn-tier package and a real retainer is not the price. It is everything on the green flags list, so judge us by it: our prices are published on the site, every month you get a plain-English update of exactly what we did and what moved, we tell you month three before you sign, we never guarantee rankings, and we bundle SEO with GEO because the same work now has to win Google and ChatGPT at once. And if SEO is not what your business needs, the free audit will say so, because Reddit is right about one more thing: if you already have more work than you can handle, you don't need us yet.
Book a free callQuestions, answered.
Is SEO worth it for a small business?+
Yes, if you can hold out for the results curve. Reddit's framing is the right one: ads are hunting, SEO is gardening. Paid ads feed you today and stop the moment you stop paying. SEO takes around three months to move and then compounds. For local service businesses, local SEO is repeatedly named the highest-return channel available.
How long does SEO take to work?+
First movement around month three. Meaningful, bankable results between month three and twelve. Anyone promising faster is lying to you, and Reddit's scam threads are full of the receipts. If nothing at all has moved by month three to five, question the provider, not the channel.
How much should SEO cost for a small business in the UK?+
Reddit's rule of thumb, converted roughly: under £400 a month is a scam, the £400 to £800 package tier from volume agencies is where most people get burned, and credible sustained work starts around £600 to £1,500 a month depending on competition. Price is not the tell though. Transparency is. Judge any provider, including us, on whether they itemise what they do each month.
Can I do SEO myself instead of hiring an agency?+
For a local service business, genuinely yes, and Reddit is full of owners who did: location-specific pages, steady Google Business Profile activity, content answering what customers actually search, a handful of real local links. The trade is your evenings. Owners hire when the time cost outgrows the fee, or when the market is too competitive for part-time effort.
What are the biggest SEO scam red flags?+
Guaranteed rankings, guaranteed backlink counts, link packages, vague monthly reports, upselling after failure, long lock-in contracts, and any provider who cold-approached you. The single best question to ask: "What exactly will you do each month, and will you show me?" Watch how they answer.
Is SEO still worth it now AI answers search questions?+
Yes, arguably more. AI assistants like ChatGPT build their recommendations on top of ordinary search results, so the work that ranks you is the same work that gets you cited by AI. That is why we sell SEO and GEO as one retainer, not two. We read the Reddit threads on that debate too, summarised on our AI SEO page.
Get found, and know exactly what you paid for.
Book a free call. We will tell you honestly if SEO is worth it for your business, including when the answer is not yet.
Or email: hello@sorttheclicks.com