If your current website brings in enquiries from Google, the biggest risk in a redesign is losing that traffic the week the new site goes live. It happens when old page addresses disappear and nobody tells Google where they went. The fix is a redirect map and a checklist, and both are cheap next to the work you lose without them.
This is the checklist we use on every redesign, with two examples from our own work: a gym that moved 114 pages to a new domain and a flooring contractor that changed its name.
Does a website redesign affect SEO?
Yes, whenever addresses, content or the domain change, and it can be managed.
Google ranks each page on its own. Each page on your current site has its own position, built up from its content, its age and the links pointing at it. A redesign that renames /services/loft-conversions to /loft-conversions/ has created a new page as far as Google is concerned. If the old address now shows a "page not found" error, its ranking goes with it.
Google's guidance on site moves says to expect "ranking fluctuations while Google recrawls and reindexes your site". For small and medium sites it says most pages move in a few weeks. A short wobble is normal. A lasting drop usually means pages were lost.
The checklist: nine steps to keep your rankings
Inventory, map, redirect, keep the content, then check and watch.
| Step | What you do | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| 1. URL inventory | List every address on the old site: pages, blog posts, project pages, PDFs, images that get traffic | You cannot redirect a page you do not know exists |
| 2. Find what earns | Pull the top pages from Search Console and analytics, plus pages with links from other sites | These are the pages you protect first |
| 3. Redirect map | A spreadsheet: old URL in one column, its closest new page in the next | Each old page passes its history to one new page |
| 4. 301 redirects | Permanent server redirects, one step each, no chains | Google treats a 301 as a permanent move |
| 5. Content parity | Keep the words, titles and headings that rank, then improve them | A new page with half the content may not hold the old position |
| 6. Structured data | Carry across LocalBusiness, FAQ and review schema; check with Google's Rich Results Test | Keeps rich results and helps AI answers read the site |
| 7. Launch checks | Remove any noindex left from the staging site, check robots.txt, test forms | A forgotten noindex can hide the whole site |
| 8. Tell Google | Submit the new sitemap; use the Change of Address tool if the domain changed | Speeds up recrawling and the transfer of history |
| 9. Watch | Check Search Console every few days for four to six weeks | Catches broken redirects and dropped pages while they are easy to fix |
Steps 1 to 3: know every page before you change any
Start from the full list of what exists today, then decide where each page goes.
Crawl the old site with a tool such as Screaming Frog, then add anything the crawl misses from Search Console's pages report and the old sitemap. Older sites often have project pages and blog posts that no menu links to any more but still get found on Google. Mark the pages that bring in clicks and enquiries. Then give every old address a new home: the closest matching page, never the homepage by default. An old "flat roof repairs Watford" page should land on the new flat roofing page, because that is what the person searching wanted.
Step 4: permanent redirects, one hop each
Use 301 redirects set on the server, and send each old address straight to its final page.
Google's guidance asks for server-side permanent redirects (301 or 308) and warns against chains, where one redirect points to another. It says to keep them "generally at least 1 year", and to consider keeping them for good. Do not forget the variants: the www and non-www versions, and http as well as https, all need to forward.
Steps 5 and 6: keep what ranks, then improve it
Move the content that earns traffic across intact, then build on it.
A redesign is a good moment to rewrite thin pages. Be careful with the pages that already rank. Keep their main heading, their title and the substance of the text, and add to them. Carry across structured data too, so Google still knows your business type, address, service area and opening hours.
Steps 7 to 9: launch, tell Google, then watch
Check the basics on launch day, then watch Search Console closely for a month.
A common launch mistake is a "noindex" tag carried over from the test version of the site. It tells Google not to show any page, and it can sit unnoticed for weeks. Check the live homepage source on launch day. Then submit the new sitemap, and if the domain changed, file a Change of Address in Search Console for the old domain. In the weeks after, look at the page indexing report and the 404 list. Any old address returning an error needs a redirect.
What this looked like on a real move: 228 old addresses
Huntsman Training Club moved domain and platform and every old address still lands on the right page.
Huntsman Training Club, a CrossFit and Hyrox gym in Hertford Heath, renamed itself from CrossFit Huntsman in autumn 2026. We replaced its old WordPress site on crossfithuntsman.com with a new site on huntsmantrainingclub.co.uk, live on 30 September 2026.
- We listed the old site's 114 page addresses and mapped each one to its matching new page.
- Each address works with and without www, so that is 228 old web addresses. All 228 forward in a single step to the right new page, and all were tested on launch night.
- Google accepted the Change of Address from the old domain the same evening.
- Two days later a check found the old sitemap and feed addresses landing on the homepage. Six extra rules now send them to the new sitemap.
That last point is why step 9 exists. Small gaps show up in the first week, and they are easy to fix while you are looking.
Changing your business name or domain
A new domain needs the same redirect map, plus the Change of Address tool.
Guild Floors was JG Floors Ltd until 2026. When we rebranded the business and built its new site, the old domain jgfloorsltd.com was set to redirect page for page to guildfloors.co.uk. Today jgfloorsltd.com/contact still lands on guildfloors.co.uk/contact. Old links from directories, suppliers and past customers keep working, and the search history carried across. The first website enquiry came from ChatGPT six days after launch. Read the Guild Floors case study.
We did the same for D J Carroll Roofing, where every address on the old djcarrollroofingltd.co.uk domain now forwards to the new site. Keep the old domain registered for good. If it lapses, the redirects stop and someone else can buy it.
Questions to ask your agency before the redesign starts
If an agency cannot answer these in plain English, your rankings are at risk.
- Will you list every URL on our current site before you design anything?
- Will we see the redirect map before launch, and who tests it?
- How do you keep the content on our best pages?
- Who checks Search Console after launch, and for how long?
- Is the redirect work in the quote, or extra?
Our guide to choosing a web design company has the full list of questions to ask before you sign.
What it costs to do this properly
Redirect and migration work is a small line on a redesign quote and the cheapest insurance you can buy.
On our quotes, a redirect and domain move costs £350 where the web address changes, alongside a multi-page site from £2,899. Our redesign cost guide breaks down every line. If you run a construction or trade business, our construction marketing guide covers how the site fits with Google and AI search afterwards.
If you are planning a redesign and want a second pair of eyes on the move, our website service covers the full migration, and our SEO and AI search retainers keep watching after launch. Book a 30-minute call and bring your current site; we will show you which pages matter most before anything changes.