If your customers have started asking ChatGPT who to hire, you probably want an agency that can get you named in those answers. The way to choose one is to ask to see the reporting first. A good AI search agency tracks 10 to 20 of your buyers' questions in ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews every week, shows which of your pages get cited, counts ChatGPT visits in Google Analytics, and lists what it changed on your site that month.
Most agencies now say they do AI search. This guide shows you how to tell which ones actually measure it, the ten questions to ask on the first call, and the answers that should worry you.
AEO, GEO and AI search are the same job
AEO, GEO and AI search all mean getting your business named and linked inside AI answers.
Agencies use different names for positioning. The work underneath is the same: pages that answer real questions, prices and areas written on the site, proof such as reviews and case studies, structured data, and the same business details everywhere your company is listed. Most of it overlaps with SEO. Google says there are no extra requirements to appear in AI Overviews beyond its normal search guidance (Google Search Central). So judge an agency on what it does and how it reports, whichever acronym it uses.
What good AI search reporting looks like
Good reporting shows you the questions your buyers ask, whether you appear in the answers, and what the agency did about it.
Here is what a useful monthly report contains, and where each number comes from.
| What is reported | What it tells you | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| A fixed list of 10 to 20 buyer prompts, checked weekly | Whether ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews name you when someone asks "best builder in Hertford" or "who fits commercial flooring in Essex" | An AI visibility tracking tool, run on the same prompts every week so the trend means something |
| Who else gets named | Which competitors win the answers you want | The same prompt tracking |
| Which pages get cited | Which of your pages AI tools trust, and which pages to improve next | The links shown in each AI answer |
| Visits from ChatGPT | Whether being mentioned turns into people on your site | Google Analytics, where these visits show as coming from chatgpt.com |
| Google clicks and impressions | How you are doing on Google, including AI Overviews | Search Console. Google counts AI Overviews and AI Mode inside the normal Web figures |
| Enquiries by source | Which channel brought the phone calls and forms | Form tracking, call tracking, and asking every enquiry how they found you |
| What changed this month | Whether the work you paid for happened | The agency's own changelog |
The first row matters most. AI answers change from day to day, so a single screenshot proves very little. A fixed set of prompts checked every week shows you the trend. Ask any agency to show you their prompt list for a current client, with the name hidden.
Ten questions to ask an SEO agency about AI search
These questions show you quickly whether an agency measures AI search or just mentions it.
| Ask | A good answer | A weak answer |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Which prompts will you track for us? | They suggest real buyer questions for your trade and area, and agree the list with you | "We track your keywords" |
| 2. Which AI tools do you check, and how often? | Named tools, at least ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews, weekly | "All of them" with no frequency |
| 3. Can I see a real report? | They show one, with the client's name hidden | A sample made for sales calls |
| 4. What lands on my site each month? | A number of articles and fixes, and what kind of fixes | "Ongoing optimisation" |
| 5. How do you count visits and enquiries from ChatGPT? | Google Analytics referrals plus enquiry tracking | They have not thought about it |
| 6. Who does the work? | Named people, and who you speak to each month | It changes or goes overseas without being said |
| 7. What do you need from me? | Prices, areas, photos, reviews, project details, sign-off on articles | Nothing at all |
| 8. What happens in the first 90 days? | Foundations in month one, first articles, a baseline of where you stand | A promise of results by a date |
| 9. Do you guarantee positions or citations? | No, and they explain what they control instead | Yes |
| 10. What is the minimum term and notice period? | A clear answer in writing | "We'll sort that out later" |
Question 9 catches more agencies than any other. Nobody controls what ChatGPT or Google says. An agency can control the quality of your pages, your business details, your reviews and how often it measures. That is what you are paying for.
Red flags when choosing an AI search agency
Walk away if the agency cannot show its tracking, guarantees results, or sells AI search as one line on an old SEO package.
- No prompt list. If they cannot tell you which questions they will track, they cannot tell you whether anything improved.
- Guaranteed citations. AI tools change how they answer all the time. Anyone promising you will be "number one in ChatGPT" is guessing.
- AI search added to an SEO package with no new work. Ask what they do differently for AI search. If the answer is one bullet about FAQ markup, the price has gone up and the work has not.
- Reports with no changelog. A report full of charts and nothing about what was done tells you how you did. It does not tell you what you paid for.
- Nobody checks your site can be read. ChatGPT's search crawler is called OAI-SearchBot, and OpenAI's crawler documentation says sites that block it will not be shown in ChatGPT search answers. A decent agency checks your settings in the first week.
What AI search from an agency costs
Done-for-you SEO and AI search for a UK business usually costs £500 to £1,500 a month.
Monitoring-only offers start under £100 a month and enterprise agencies charge £5,000 and up. Our guide to UK GEO and AEO agencies lists sixteen providers with the prices they publish. Our own retainers are £300, £500 and £900 a month, and the detail is on our SEO and AI search service page. For the wider picture on SEO pricing, read how much SEO costs in the UK.
What it looks like when it works
When the foundations are right, the first AI enquiry can arrive within days of a new site going live.
We rebranded JG Floors Ltd as Guild Floors, built a new multi-page website and run their SEO, AI search and social every month. The site went live on 11 September 2026. Six days later the first website enquiry came in, and it came from ChatGPT. In the first four weeks Guild had three leads worth £106,500 including VAT: two website enquiries through ChatGPT and a commercial tender through LinkedIn.
If you run a construction or trade business, our guide to marketing for construction companies shows how this fits with your website, Google Business Profile and reviews.
How we report AI search
We track a fixed list of buyer prompts in ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews every week, and every monthly report says what changed.
Each report covers Google rankings and clicks, where AI tools mention you and which pages they cite, visits from ChatGPT and other AI tools in Google Analytics, and a changelog of the work shipped that month. Automated checks run weekly, so if traffic drops or your AI visibility swings you hear about it the same week. You can see how we work on our AEO agency page.
Whichever agency you choose, ask to see the report first. If you would like to see where you stand today, book a free Audit and we will run one of your buyers' questions through ChatGPT live on the call.